News · United States

India Objects to US PERM Suspension and Vance’s ‘Indentured Servants’ Remark

New Delhi’s Ministry of External Affairs warned that the US Department of Labor’s halt on permanent‑labor certifications for eight firms could affect green‑card pipelines, while condemning a vice‑presidential comment as historically loaded and offensive.

India Objects to US PERM Suspension and Vance’s ‘Indentured Servants’ Remark
Author
Democracy News Live Desk
Date
9 Oct 2026
Read
2 min
The Suspension That Sparked the Row

The United States Department of Labor placed a suspension on Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) applications for eight companies. The affected firms named in the statement were major Indian IT providers Cognizant, Infosys, Tata Consultancy Services, Wipro and HCL, together with the multinational technology companies Microsoft, Adobe and Capgemini. The MEA noted that the move does not disturb existing H‑1B visas but may influence the green‑card process for workers seeking permanent residency.

Coverage
India’s Formal Response on October 9

On October 9, India’s Ministry of External Affairs issued a statement addressing the PERM suspension. The ministry clarified that while current H‑1B holders remain unaffected, the action could impact pathways to permanent residence. It also emphasized that talent mobility benefits both economies, even as it argued that the US measure does not advance shared ambitions.

Talent Mobility and Shared Ambitions

The MEA acknowledged that the exchange of skilled professionals brings considerable advantage to India and the United States. It contended that the Department of Labor’s decision does not advance shared ambitions.

It contended that the Department of Labor’s decision does not advance shared ambitions.

The Offensive Remark

The statement took sharp aim at remarks made by US Vice President JD Vance, who had described H‑1B workers as "indentured servants." India’s external affairs office said such language is unwarranted and overlooks the high education and skill levels of Indian professionals employed in the United States.

Dr. Josh C. Simmons
@drjoshcsimmons
Follow

Vance and DOL took a victory lap yesterday for freezing Microsoft's PERM green card filings. Amazon and Google paused theirs back in 2023. Microsoft filed 3,161, the most in America. The freeze touches none of its H-1Bs. American workers got a press conference. https://t.co/kzuSLcyVHv

11:17 PM · 09 Oct 2026
1221353
Historical Resonance

Going further, the MEA warned that invoking terminology with painful historical and colonial legacy connotations is deeply offensive. It stressed that such wording ignores the contributions of skilled immigrants to the American economy.

Official Quotes and Press Reaction

The ministry offered three distinct quotations: first, "This is therefore an area of tremendous mutual benefit for the two countries"; second, "We believe that such descriptions are unwarranted and ignore the fact that Indian professionals in the United States are highly educated and skilled contributors to its economy and innovation ecosystem"; and third, "Resorting to terminology that carries painful historical and colonial legacy connotations is deeply offensive." A press release reiterated the criticism, noting that "India on Friday criticised the United States over its decision to suspend PERM applications involving eight Indian IT firms."

tsnmedia
@tsnmediahub
Follow

🛂 The US Labor Dept has suspended Microsoft, Adobe and six IT firms from the PERM green-card process. It covers new and pending applications, not existing green cards. The fraud claims are allegations. No findings are published. h/t @RapidResponse47 https://t.co/8uM4bH9Fwz https://t.co/7yqIhZHp0e

11:19 PM · 09 Oct 2026
0012442
Chronology and Numbers

The numerical detail supplied is that eight companies were subjected to the PERM halt, and the date of the initial Indian response is October 9.

Where Things Stand Now

At present, the exchange reflects India’s criticism of the US PERM suspension and the remarks by JD Vance. The MEA noted that talent mobility benefits both economies.

← Back to DNL